Case 3 · outliers · mean v median
One class, 3,667 answers
1Ask
On 12 November I looked at the last four weeks: 13,664 answers in 28 days, a mean of 488 a day. I was pleased. That looked like growth. Was it?
2Collect
Then I looked at the days. On Tuesday 3 November a single class in Malaysia answered 3,667 questions. On 23 October a class in Wales answered 3,099. Take those two days out and the other 26 days average 265. Two classes, on two days, had nearly doubled my "typical" day.
| Mon 2 | Tue 3 | Wed 4 | Thu 5 | Fri 6 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 108 | 3,667 | 402 | 228 | 578 |
3Picture it
Answers each day, 15 October to 11 November 2026
The two tall bars are single classes.
Show the figures as a table
| Day | Answers | Whole-class day |
|---|---|---|
| Thu 15 Oct | 513 | no |
| Fri 16 Oct | 451 | no |
| Sat 17 Oct | 71 | no |
| Sun 18 Oct | 140 | no |
| Mon 19 Oct | 214 | no |
| Tue 20 Oct | 142 | no |
| Wed 21 Oct | 118 | no |
| Thu 22 Oct | 586 | no |
| Fri 23 Oct | 3,099 | yes |
| Sat 24 Oct | 85 | no |
| Sun 25 Oct | 124 | no |
| Mon 26 Oct | 732 | no |
| Tue 27 Oct | 172 | no |
| Wed 28 Oct | 735 | no |
| Thu 29 Oct | 80 | no |
| Fri 30 Oct | 27 | no |
| Sat 31 Oct | 51 | no |
| Sun 1 Nov | 93 | no |
| Mon 2 Nov | 108 | no |
| Tue 3 Nov | 3,667 | yes |
| Wed 4 Nov | 402 | no |
| Thu 5 Nov | 228 | no |
| Fri 6 Nov | 578 | no |
| Sat 7 Nov | 228 | no |
| Sun 8 Nov | 115 | no |
| Mon 9 Nov | 310 | no |
| Tue 10 Nov | 357 | no |
| Wed 11 Nov | 238 | no |
4Decide
A value that sits far away from the rest is an outlier. The mean adds every value, so one outlier drags it a long way. The median only looks at the middle value, so it barely notices. This is why the Office for National Statistics reports the median wage as its headline figure for pay. A few very high earners pull the mean up, so the mean describes nobody's pay packet. The median is what the person in the middle earns. So when we talk about a typical day now, we use the median, and we report big class days on their own.
What this data can't tell us
- We can't be certain a big day is one class: we see a burst of answers from one country in a short time, not who sent them.
- Answers aren't students.
- Our own testing is in the numbers.